Rule based reasoning legal writing and research

The rule would be satisfied if the facts of the present case satisfies all the elements of the rule. For this reason, you should make sure that your Explanation of your Rule effectively lays out the specific factors that you will address in your Analysis.

Each of the major projects in LRW should demonstrate that, with regard to a given legal problem, there is usually more than one possible outcome, even if one outcome seems more likely than the others. Skilled lawyers read authorities with a critical eye, constantly on the lookout for the gap of ambiguity within a seemingly solid wall of legal authorities.

Petersen took sufficient precautions in guarding the secrecy of the PPI System. These techniques will also help you find ways to attack unfavourable cases. However, when you are just getting started, try to stick to one case per sentence.

Once you have identified those factors and chosen the factors that you wish to discuss, you will analyze those factors one-by-one. The rule applies to both personal injury and property damage.

Dimitri about her plans to copyright the system so that no other fitness centers could use it, and Ms. In the fall semester, you will complete two major writing assignments.

Course Overview

Another benefit to organizing your Analysis according to the factors that you identified in your Explanation is that you will then naturally organize your writing by factor or theme, according to the nature of the law, and not simply by case.

Take it all with a grain of salt. Indeed, without such skills you will have a difficult time satisfying your employers and competing with fellow students in summer practice and the early years of law practice.

A person who owns a toy poodle that escapes and causes personal injury is not strictly liable for that personal injury. After your topic sentence, discuss relevant case law to demonstrate how courts have previously treated the issue, preferably in situations relatively similar to yours.

I have found that the easiest way to succinctly discuss a case in a single sentence is with the following format: For example, if an ex-boyfriend calls an ex-girlfriend several times in the middle of the night to harass her outrageous conduct; intentional conduct and this causes causation her severe emotional distress element 4intentional infliction of emotional distress has taken place.

However, the court explained that there always are more security precautions that can be taken, just because there is something else that could have been done does not mean that the efforts were unreasonable under the circumstances.

One such factor is the contingent nature of language. If you feel that you have too much to discuss, then you might consider breaking your discussion out into further subsections.

Navigating this Blog There are countless ways to style legal writing. You will learn what types of materials constitute acceptable sources of authority in legal discourse, as well as the different hierarchies within which those authorities exist.

The easiest way to ensure that your Analysis section is well organized and compelling is to follow the road map that you should have provided in your Explanation.

Legal writers often refer to this thematic approach as "rule-based reasoning. The two cases are never exact; reasoning by analogy is a question of degree. Begin with a topic sentence that identifies the theme of the paragraph; b.

Discuss relevant facts from those cases - the facts that pertain to the sub-issue that you are discussing in the subsection, and c. Of course, you will be learning the conventions of legal discourse in all of your first-year courses, indeed in all of law school.

Discourse conventions govern not only the modes of argument, but also the authorities that frame the argument.

Review and assess the case law

Discuss the case law in comparison to your case to demonstrate the likelihood of success for your client, analogizing to the cases where the court ruled favorably and distinguishing from those where the court ruled unfavorably.

Policy-based reasoning can also be combined with reasoning by analogy. In rule-based reasoning, you take a rule a statute or a case holding and apply it to a set of facts.

More advanced research instruction is available in upper-level elective courses. Analyse the cases It is unusual for a legal rule to be stated consistently throughout a line of cases. Following your opening paragraph to your subsection are your Analysis paragraphs. LRW meets weekly in the fall and spring semester of your first year.

Judges are drawn from Harvard Law School faculty, practicing lawyers, and upper-level law students.Rule-based reasoning. Another benefit to organizing your Analysis according to the factors that you identified in your Explanation is that you will then naturally organize your writing by factor or theme, according to the nature of the law, and not simply by case.

In this study, rules-based reasoning involves a straightforward transformation process of legal statute to rule form. The purpose of this transformation is to identify and select the rules.

Professors share top advice for better legal writing December | Around the ABA She provides examples of two forms of legal reasoning expressed through our writing: rule-based (or deductive) reasoning and analogical (or inductive) reasoning.

Professors share top advice for better legal writing. LEGAL RESEARCH, LEGAL WRITING, AND LEGAL ANALYSIS: PUTTING LAW SCHOOL INTO PRACTICE approaches are steeped in the cases, statutes, and rules that the lawyer has located through thorough research.

Lawyering; Legal Skills; Legal Research and Writing; Legal Reasoning, Research, and Writing; Legal Writing; and Communication and Legal.

Rule-based reasoning is the most important type of legal reasoning. In rule-based reasoning, you take a rule (a statute or a case holding) and apply it. Chapter 2 Rule-Based Reasoning 9 Chapter 3 Issues, Facts, Precedents, and Statutes 23 PART II INTRODUCTION TO LEGAL WRITING 37 Chapter 4 Predictive Writing 39 Reprinted from Neumann: Legal Reasoning and Legal Writing with the permission of Wolters Kluwer Law and Business.).

Download
Rule based reasoning legal writing and research
Rated 4/5 based on 59 review