1812 the war that forged a nation thesis

Equally important was the outspoken desire of many Westerners, including Andrew Jackson and William 1812 the war that forged a nation thesis Harrison, to annex more territory, including as much of Canada as the US could grab.

Borneman does an excellent job of describing the processes of naval combat in the early 19th century and still manages to keep to his narrative story telling style. Walter BornemanThe War that Forged a Nation, has been published in paperback in after a hardback printing in None of these actions by the British government, in of themselves, were enough to push the United States towards a war that hardly anyone wanted.

Led by Admiral Cockman and General Ross, the expedentiary force burned Washington, while President Madison was powerless to direct his cabinet or local militia in the defense of the American homeland.

In a sense, Aaron Burr was right in saying that the war was fought over what he had been accussed of treason of 10 years before.

1812, The War that Forged a Nation: Book Review

The book could have been a bit stronger in reference to the societal reactions to the war throughout the United States and British Canda more attention could have been paid to the political machinations of the time.

His point being that America was so fractured by internal desires for power that even a high member of government, from the most conservative of families was willing to give up on the idea of the American republic.

The English practice of impressing seamen from American vessels was the most widely cited casus belli at the time and the one most of us read about in high-school history class. Borneman argues, perhaps a bit too glibly, that the war effectively cemented the American union in the eyes of its citizens.

The US and British acheived many tactical successes, but due to faulty command and control, neither side acheived a strategic victory worthy of the sacrifice of lives that were billed to both sides. Borneman does a good job of showing how the American war was, in English eyes, a sideshow to the struggles taking place in Europe.

But the war was the last armed conflict involving a European power in North America after nearly years since the English military set foot at Jamestown and the wars of American colonial empire began in earnest.

The War of was in fact, two wars, fought over four different theatres of operation by an American military that was completely ill-prepared for battle in terms of supplies, personel and a distinct chain of command system.

Only the defenses of Fort McHenry, which inspired Francis Scott Key were enough to discourage the British to aim their efforts at the US gulf coast, ending with the post treaty battle of New Orleans, where Andrew Jackson laid the foundation for his national rise to power.

America now belonged to the settlers moving west to Ohio, Illinois and Tennessee. The third theatre of operations on American soil was narrowly focused and the only real British offensive of the war that occurred during the lull in the wars with Napoleon before Waterloo, when the British had the manpower to devote to ending the American cause.

The border with British Canada became a vast, peaceful marker in the Anglosphere, not region of constant dispute.

Never again would America be seriously challenged from an outside invader. The American national anthem, the Star-Spangled Banner, was written after the seige of Baltimore, the capital city was burned by an invading army, the US Navy acheived some of its greatest acheivements this side of Midway and the nation had its last real fight with a European power until World War I considering the Spainish American War of was more of a routand it was the last time until Pearl Harbor in that America was attacked on its own soil by a foreign power.

A solid performance, though, placing key events in a larger perspective without playing down the vast stupidity of many of the participants. Borneman has included excellent maps in his narrative, but could probably include in the sweep of his story the mental pictures of the empty vastness of the Great Lakes frontier and its Niagra Falls wilderness.

Wellington was one of several English generals who declined the command of the armies sent to America, which by included veterans of the Napoleonic wars.

The second theatre of operations, the war on the Canadian frontier, occupies the greatest amount of text in the book as well as action in the war.


There was a problem adding your email address. The war forged an American nation in that it took political power forever away from New England as a region.

For the casual reader of American history, this book is reccommended as an enjoyable read and a solid introduction to a little understood time period of American history. Much of the war was fought on the Canadian front, including several key naval battles on the Great Lakes.

Walter R. Borneman

It contains excellent maps for a popular history book. Borneman illustrates his thesis by how he starts his narrative, 10 years before the conflict, when former Vice President Aaron Burr was tried for a conspiracy to wrest much of the western United States away from the Federal government.

James Madison, vastly unpopular in New England which seriously considered seceding from the Unionsent his best diplomats to attempt to negotiate a truce; England was willing, but saw no urgency to give in on the issue of impressment.

Not much is known of this war in popular memory, which is a shame.The War That Forged a Nation by Walter R. Borneman This readable narrative of the War of places the war in the context of America's development as a nation and emphasizes its importance as a foundation of America's subsequent westward expansion/5(14).

This thoroughly readable popular history of the War of may exaggerate in its claim that the war forged America's national identity; after all, there were enough regional identities left lying around after the conflict to cause a national civil war.

Here’s an excerpt detailing the battle between the USS Constitution and the HMS Guerriere on August 19, Hey, of course they were battling, right? From The War That Forged a Nation (P.S.), by Walter R.

Borneman. Treaty of Ghent - Signed on December 24, in the Belgian town of Ghent, the Treaty of Ghent ended the War ofreturning the situation between the US and Britain to its status quo ante bellum (the way things were before the war).The War that Forged a Nation: Book Review | Greersights Mar 14, · Walter Borneman’sThe War that Forged a Nation, is a narrative popular history with a thesis designed to get the reader to understand the.

1812: The War That Forged a Nation

Western historian Borneman (Alaska,etc.) argues that the war ofoften dismissed as a sideshow to European events, had a profound impact on US history. He begins by examining the conflict’s origins. The English practice of impressing seamen from American vessels was the most widely.

1812 the war that forged a nation thesis
Rated 4/5 based on 83 review